PI Review Mentor Evaluation Network
As one of the founders of the USTC Course Evaluation Community, I am willing to promote the 2021 effort of several collaborators on my personal homepage: PI Review (https://pi-review.com/).
It has been 7 years since the establishment of the Course Evaluation Community in 2015. The community now has over 16,000 reviews and has a significant influence among USTC students. Many students refer to the reviews on the community when selecting courses. Anyone who has pursued a PhD or Master’s degree would likely agree that a mentor is crucial to a student’s life and future during these years. Although there are already many websites for evaluating mentors, such as Mentor Recommendation, Rate My Supervisor, and Research Control, they all have many issues. Here is a more detailed evaluation. The founders of PI Review discovered that there was no satisfactory website, so they established PI Review in 2021 and have added many new features this year.
PI Review operates on an anonymous basis. You only need to verify with your school email to post reviews, but the email verification is solely to prevent spam. Email addresses will never be made public, and we will not send spam emails. All posted reviews are anonymous. We welcome everyone to share their own or their friends’ mentors. If you think a mentor is good, you can help yourself by bringing collaborators on board. If you think a mentor is not good, you can help junior students avoid pitfalls.
PI Review currently suggests evaluating mentors across 5 dimensions, including Advisor Style & Mentorship (hands-on or hands-off, etc.), Expectations (publishing papers, work hours, etc.), Funding & Support (salary, internships, etc.), Research, and Lab Culture. Of course, this is just a reference, and you can evaluate mentors according to your own dimensions.
During my own PhD period, both of my Microsoft co-supervised mentors were very good to me, providing a lot of guidance and help. I have also written reviews on PI Review. If you are interested, you can look them up. The search function for mentors should be quite useful.